Historical Apoplexy · State Legislative Adaptations · Montana
Montana Food, Resource, and Commodity Assurance Act
A state legislative adaptation of the Historical Apoplexy framework
SIXTY-NINTH LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF MONTANA
2025 Regular Session
HOUSE/SENATE BILL ____
BY __________ (Introduced by request)
CONCERNING THE ESTABLISHMENT OF STATE PROGRAMS FOR FOOD AND COMMODITY ASSURANCE, PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELFARE, AND EDUCATION MODERNIZATION TO ENSURE THE MATERIAL SECURITY, PHYSIOLOGICAL WELL-BEING, AND DEVELOPMENTAL MATURITY OF ALL MONTANA RESIDENTS, AND, IN CONNECTION THEREWITH, AMENDING TITLES 20, 50, 53, AND 80 OF THE MONTANA CODE ANNOTATED, MAKING APPROPRIATIONS, AND PROVIDING EFFECTIVE DATES.
A BILL FOR AN ACT
LONG TITLE
AN ACT CONCERNING THE CREATION OF THE MONTANA FOOD, RESOURCE, AND COMMODITY ASSURANCE ACT, AND, IN CONNECTION THEREWITH, ESTABLISHING THE MONTANA FOOD ASSURANCE PROGRAM BY ADDING A NEW PART TO TITLE 80, CHAPTER 1, OF THE MONTANA CODE ANNOTATED; CREATING THE MONTANA ESSENTIAL GOODS PROGRAM BY ADDING A NEW PART TO TITLE 90, CHAPTER 1, OF THE MONTANA CODE ANNOTATED; ESTABLISHING THE MONTANA PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELFARE FINDINGS BY AMENDING TITLE 50, CHAPTER 1, OF THE MONTANA CODE ANNOTATED; ENACTING THE MONTANA EDUCATION MODERNIZATION ACT BY AMENDING TITLE 20, CHAPTER 7, AND ADDING A NEW CHAPTER TO TITLE 20 OF THE MONTANA CODE ANNOTATED; ESTABLISHING THE MONTANA PUBLIC SERVICE AND RESOURCE LIBRARY PROGRAM BY ADDING A NEW PART TO TITLE 2, CHAPTER 15, OF THE MONTANA CODE ANNOTATED; REQUIRING PARTNERSHIP WITH MONTANA'S FEDERALLY RECOGNIZED TRIBAL NATIONS IN ALL PROGRAM DIVISIONS PURSUANT TO ARTICLE X, SECTION 1(2) OF THE MONTANA CONSTITUTION; MAKING APPROPRIATIONS; AND PROVIDING FOR EFFECTIVE DATES AND IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULES.
LEGISLATIVE ROUTING NOTE
Montana has a citizen ballot initiative process. Under Article III, Section 4 of the Montana Constitution, the people may enact laws by initiative on all matters except appropriations of money and local or special laws. Because this act includes appropriations, it must be introduced through the Legislature. However, the substantive programs established herein may also be proposed as a separate non-appropriation initiative statute.
The signature requirement for a statutory initiative is five percent (5%) of the total votes cast for governor in the most recent gubernatorial election. Based on the 2024 gubernatorial election, the approximate threshold for a statutory initiative is 30,180 valid signatures, collected from at least thirty-four (34) of Montana's one hundred (100) House districts (one-third plus one). For a constitutional initiative, the threshold is ten percent (10%), or approximately 60,359 signatures from at least forty (40) House districts.
FILING: An initiated statute is filed with the Montana Secretary of State pursuant to MCA 13-27-201 through 13-27-312. The Attorney General prepares the ballot statement. The Legislative Services Division conducts a legal sufficiency review.
Alternatively, this bill may be introduced through the Legislature by any member of the Senate or House of Representatives.
COMMITTEE ASSIGNMENT: Upon introduction, this bill would likely be assigned to: - Senate Agriculture, Livestock, and Irrigation Committee or House
Agriculture Committee (Division I)
- Senate Public Health, Welfare, and Safety Committee or House
Human Services Committee (Division II)
- Senate Education and Cultural Resources Committee or House
Education Committee (Division III)
Because the bill spans multiple committees' jurisdictions, it may be assigned to an Appropriations Committee or referred jointly.
FISCAL NOTE: The Legislative Fiscal Division prepares fiscal notes for all bills with budgetary impact per Montana Joint Rule 30-60.
FLOOR VOTE: Simple majority in each chamber (26 of 50 Senators; 51 of 100 Representatives). Governor's signature or veto override (two-thirds of each chamber).
SESSION: The 69th Legislature (2025). Montana legislative sessions convene on the first Monday in January of odd-numbered years and last no more than ninety (90) legislative days unless extended by two-thirds vote.
HISTORY: A version of this proposal was first developed in 2016 through the Sassafras and Maple Research Foundation (SMRF), the first non-partisan political trade school in the United States, registered with the Colorado Department of Higher Education, Division of Private Occupational Schools (DPOS). The original proposal was drafted for Colorado and sidelined during the 2016-2017 legislative cycle. The present version has been adapted for the State of Montana, incorporating updated research from the Historical Apoplexy series (Cooper, 2025-2026), a ten-paper academic work providing the evidentiary foundation for this legislation.
LEGISLATIVE DECLARATION
Be it enacted by the Legislature of the State of Montana:
SECTION 1. Legislative findings and declaration.
(1) The Legislature hereby finds, determines, and declares that:
FINDINGS RELATING TO MONTANA'S CONSTITUTIONAL MANDATE:
(a) The Montana Constitution of 1972, drafted by one hundred (100)
delegates in Helena from January 17 through March 11, 1972, in
response to the Anaconda Copper Mining Company's decades of
political domination of the state, established among the most
progressive individual rights provisions of any state constitution
in the United States;
(b) Article II, Section 3 of the Montana Constitution guarantees
the right to a "clean and healthful environment," one of the
strongest environmental rights provisions in any state
constitution. Article II, Section 10 guarantees the right to
privacy. Article X, Section 1(2) commits the state to the
preservation of the cultural integrity of Montana's American
Indian populations. This act operationalizes these constitutional
commitments;
(c) The 1972 Constitutional Convention was driven by populist
opposition to corporate extraction — specifically the Anaconda
Company's control of Montana's press, legislature, and judiciary.
The delegates wrote a constitution to prevent extraction interests
from controlling the state's governance. This act extends that
anti-extraction principle from governance to the material economy:
the 75.7 percent markup between food production cost and retail
price is the same extraction mechanism that the 1972 delegates
sought to prevent, applied to commerce rather than politics;
FINDINGS RELATING TO THE STRUCTURAL IMPERATIVE FOR STATE
ACTION:
(a0) Twenty-two federal government shutdowns since 1976,
including a forty-three-day shutdown in 2025. The House frozen
at 435 since 1929; 762,000 constituents per representative —
worst in the OECD. Federal H.R. 1 (2025) shifted SNAP
administrative costs from fifty percent to seventy-five percent
state share. The federal machine is structurally overloaded
(Cooper, Paper VII, 2026). This state has the authority to act
under its own legislative power rather than await federal
action that structural overload prevents;
(a1) DENIAL IS NO LONGER NEUTRAL. Inaction by a legislature
possessing the authority, capacity, and documented need to act
constitutes active harm. The burden rests on denial;
FINDINGS RELATING TO FOOD AND COMMODITY INSECURITY:
(d) According to the Food Research & Action Center and the United
States Department of Agriculture Economic Research Service,
approximately eleven percent (11%) of Montana households
experience food insecurity. The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance
Program (SNAP) serves approximately 80,271 Montanans, bringing
$169,446,871 to the state in fiscal year 2024 (FRAC, SNAP State
Fact Sheet — Montana, February 2025);
(e) Montana's agricultural sector generates approximately $4.6
billion in annual cash receipts from farm marketings (USDA
National Agricultural Statistics Service; University of Arkansas
Division of Agriculture, Economic Impact of Agriculture —
Montana, 2022). The state has approximately 58.1 million acres
of land in farms and ranches, ranking second in the nation behind
Texas. Montana's top agricultural products include cattle and
calves, wheat, hay, barley, and lentils;
(f) Montana has approximately 2.12 million cattle and 1.14 million
people — nearly two cattle for every Montanan (USDA, 2024;
Montana Free Press, July 2025). The state produces more food per
capita than nearly any other state in the union, yet eleven
percent of its households cannot consistently feed themselves.
Food insecurity in Montana is a distribution problem, not a
production problem;
(g) The United States Department of Agriculture Economic Research
Service Food Dollar Series establishes that the farm share of the
United States food dollar is 24.3 cents, with the remaining 75.7
cents allocated to processing, transportation, wholesale, retail,
and food service markup. Total United States food-at-home spending
is approximately $1.09 trillion; production cost is approximately
$213 to $327 billion. The difference of approximately $496 billion
represents markup above production cost;
(h) The cost to close the food insecurity gap for all 47.9 million
food-insecure Americans is approximately $32 billion, which
represents 6.5 percent of the $496 billion markup between
production cost and retail price (Cooper, "The Mathematics of
Abundance," 2025);
(i) The United States military commissary system, established by
the Military Commissary Act of 1867 and now codified at 10 U.S.C.
Section 2484, has operated at-cost food distribution continuously
for one hundred fifty-seven (157) years through the Defense
Commissary Agency (DeCA), operating 236 stores worldwide and
delivering savings of 17 to 25 percent below civilian retail
prices to approximately 2.8 million authorized users. Malmstrom
Air Force Base in Great Falls, Montana, operates a commissary
serving military families, funded by all federal taxpayers
including Montana ranchers and farmers whose products feed the
nation but who themselves may lack consistent access to affordable
food;
(j) Montana's vast geography — 147,040 square miles, the fourth
largest state by area — combined with its sparse population of
approximately 1.14 million people at a density of 7.4 persons
per square mile creates distribution challenges unlike any other
state in this nation. Reservation communities may be fifty to one
hundred miles from the nearest full-service grocery store. The
state that maintains one hundred fifty (150) Minuteman III
intercontinental ballistic missiles across 13,800 square miles
of its prairies through the 341st Missile Wing at Malmstrom Air
Force Base can deliver a nuclear warhead to any point on earth
within thirty minutes — but cannot consistently deliver groceries
to the Blackfeet Reservation;
(k) The geographer Albrecht Penck calculated in 1925 that Earth's
carrying capacity was eight billion people using 1920s agricultural
technology. The current world population is approximately eight
billion. Since agricultural technology has advanced substantially
beyond 1920s capacity, scarcity of food is not a physical
constraint but a distribution and policy constraint (Penck, 1925;
Cohen, "How Many People Can the Earth Support?," 1995);
(l) The United States has approximately 293,000 manufacturing
facilities. Studies indicate that 10,000 to 15,000 facilities
would suffice for universal material abundance, representing 19.5
to 29.3 times overcapacity, with United States manufacturing
currently operating at approximately 77 percent capacity
utilization (Federal Reserve; Cooper, "The Mathematics of
Abundance," 2025);
(m) In 2024 alone, 7,325 retail grocery store locations closed
in the United States (Cooper, "Stolen Futures," 2025), while
54 million Americans live in food deserts. The commercial retail
grocery model is collapsing as a distribution system;
(n) The economist John Kenneth Galbraith described in "The
Affluent Society" (1958) the condition of "private opulence and
public squalor" — the coexistence of enormous private productive
capacity with inadequate public provision of basic needs. This
condition is acute in Montana, where the state produces nearly
twice as much livestock as it has people yet cannot feed all of
its residents;
(o) The economist Thorstein Veblen documented in "The Engineers
and the Price System" (1921) the deliberate restriction of
production capacity by business interests to maintain prices above
production cost, a practice he termed the "conscious withdrawal
of efficiency." The gap between Montana's productive capacity
and its residents' material security reflects this structural
dynamic;
(o.5) The industrial designer and futurist Jacque Fresco proposed
in "Designing the Future" (2007) a resource library model in
which goods are distributed according to need and tiered by
permanence: constant-need goods (food, consumables) replenished
continuously, semi-permanent goods (clothing, household supplies)
maintained and circulated, and permanent goods (durable equipment,
housing, transportation) allocated once and maintained
indefinitely. This three-tier framework, adapted from Fresco's
resource-based economy concept, provides the operational
architecture for the resource library established in Division IV
of this act;
FINDINGS RELATING TO MONTANA'S EXTRACTION HISTORY:
(p) Butte, Montana — once called "The Richest Hill on Earth" —
produced the copper that wired America's electrical grid. The
Anaconda Copper Mining Company extracted billions of dollars in
wealth from Butte and its surrounding communities. What remained
is the Berkeley Pit — a former open-pit copper mine measuring
approximately one mile by one-half mile with a maximum depth of
approximately 1,780 feet, now a federal Superfund site and one of
the largest toxic waste complexes in the United States. In
November 1995, 342 migrating snow geese landed on the pit's toxic
water and died (High Country News, December 1995; Audubon, 2016);
(q) Butte's population collapsed from over 100,000 at peak mining
to approximately 35,000 today. The town of Anaconda is a
Superfund site. The wealth extracted from Montana built corporate
empires elsewhere. The poison remained. This is the extraction
economy in its most literal form: resource extracted, profit
removed, community abandoned with the cost. The 75.7 percent
markup between food production cost and retail price is the same
mechanism in a different industry — value extracted from
production, profit taken elsewhere, communities left bearing the
cost. Division I of this act reverses the extraction model by
keeping value in the communities where it is produced;
FINDINGS RELATING TO HISTORICAL AND BIOLOGICAL PRECEDENT:
(q1) Anaconda extracted copper from Butte and left a toxic pit.
Augustus extracted taxes from Rome and fed 200,000 people with
the annona civica — grain distribution as infrastructure, same
category as roads. Suetonius records him ordering a knight stabbed
at a public assembly for taking notes. The man who did that still
fed his city. The annona ran over 400 years. Nerva added child
nutrition funded by government loans to farmers, recorded on
bronze at Veleia (CIL XI 1147) that you can still visit. At
Mabu Co in Tibet, sedentary abundance was achieved 4,400 years
ago at 14,587 feet with fishing hooks (Nature Ecology & Evolution,
2024). The Azolla Event proved one fern species could edit Earth's
atmosphere over 800,000 years (Brinkhuis et al., Nature 441,
2006). The commissary has run 157 years. The annona ran 400.
Biology works across geologic time. Montana's ranches produce
more cattle than people. The question is not production. It is
who eats;
(q2) Division I does not nationalize Montana ranching. Cattle
operations stay private. Wheat farms stay private. The state
purchases at production cost plus five percent surcharge — the
same model the commissary at Malmstrom AFB has used since 1867
without acquiring a single ranch. Currency survives for
everything above the base list. The bill is a floor;
(q3) The retail collapse and autonomous freight are already
eliminating distribution jobs. Aurora runs driverless freight
between Dallas and Houston today. Over 15,000 store closures
projected for 2025. Rural Montana grocery access was already
fragile. The bill does not cause this. The bill catches displaced
workers: Division I feeds them, Division II covers their health,
Division III provides a pipeline. The commissary has truckers.
At-cost removes the markup, not the labor;
FINDINGS RELATING TO PUBLIC HEALTH AND HIERARCHY:
(r) Sir Michael Marmot's Whitehall Studies, commencing in 1967
and continuing to the present with 10,308 subjects, established
that among British civil servants with universal healthcare, full
employment, and no absolute poverty, the lowest employment grade
experienced three times the mortality rate of the highest grade.
Standard risk factors — smoking, cholesterol, blood pressure —
explained less than forty percent of the mortality gradient. The
hierarchy itself, independent of absolute material deprivation,
produces lethal health outcomes;
(s) Dr. Robert Sapolsky's thirty-year study of wild baboon
populations in the Serengeti demonstrated that subordinate social
position produces chronically elevated cortisol, atherosclerosis,
immune suppression, and cognitive impairment. When a tuberculosis
outbreak eliminated the most aggressive males from a troop,
hierarchy collapsed, and subordinates' cortisol levels normalized,
demonstrating that the health damage was caused by the hierarchy,
not by inherent individual biology (Sapolsky, "Why Zebras Don't
Get Ulcers," 1994; "Behave," 2017);
(t) Dr. Carol Shively's thirty-year study of female macaques at
Wake Forest University demonstrated that subordinate social status
directly causes visceral fat accumulation, atherosclerosis, and
coronary artery disease, with cingulate cortex serotonin
identified as the neurological nexus linking depression to
cardiovascular disease (Shively, 2009; 2014);
(u) Dr. Elizabeth Blackburn, recipient of the 2009 Nobel Prize in
Physiology or Medicine, demonstrated that chronic psychological
stress shortens telomeres — the protective caps on chromosomal
DNA — accelerating cellular aging. Caregivers of chronically ill
children had measurably shorter telomeres proportional to years of
stress. Poverty and subordination age human beings at the
molecular level (Blackburn & Epel, "The Telomere Effect," 2017);
(v) These findings collectively establish that poverty and social
hierarchy are not merely economic conditions but medical conditions
with documented physiological pathways that produce measurable
morbidity and mortality. Food and commodity assurance programs
therefore constitute public health interventions with quantifiable
healthcare cost reduction potential;
FINDINGS RELATING TO MONTANA'S HEALTH CRISIS:
(w) Montana has ranked in the top five states for suicide rate in
the nation for thirty consecutive years. In 2022, Montana had the
highest suicide rate in the United States at 28.9 per 100,000
population (326 suicides), according to the National Vital
Statistics Report (Montana Department of Public Health and Human
Services, September 2023). Rural isolation, economic precarity,
cultural stigma around mental health, limited access to
behavioral health services, and Montana's vast geography — where
the nearest mental health provider may be hours away — produce a
hierarchy of abandonment. Marmot's gradient does not require a
visible oppressor; geographic and economic isolation produce the
same cortisol-driven health outcomes;
(x) Montana's tribal reservations experience some of the worst
health outcomes in the United States. Poverty rates on Montana's
reservations range from twenty percent (20%) on the Flathead
Reservation to thirty-eight percent (38%) on the Northern Cheyenne
Reservation (Montana Department of Labor and Industry, 2024).
Diabetes, cardiovascular disease, substance abuse, and suicide
rates on Montana's reservations are catastrophically elevated.
This is Marmot's gradient at its steepest: the colonization of
indigenous peoples imposed the most extreme status hierarchy in
American history, and the health consequences are measurable
centuries later;
(y) Montana's rural geography creates healthcare deserts measured
in hundreds of miles. Critical access hospitals serve as lifelines
across the state, but the nearest specialist may be in another
state entirely. When the nearest emergency room is one hundred
miles away, every Marmot-predicted health outcome is amplified by
geographic isolation;
(z) Article II, Section 3 of the Montana Constitution guarantees
the right to a "clean and healthful environment." Division II of
this act operationalizes that guarantee beyond environmental
contamination to include the health effects of hierarchy itself —
because the hierarchy IS the unhealthful environment for most
Montanans;
FINDINGS RELATING TO EDUCATION AND HUMAN DEVELOPMENT:
(aa) Neuroscientific research establishes that the human prefrontal
cortex — responsible for judgment, impulse control, long-term
planning, and executive function — does not fully mature until
approximately age twenty-five (25). The current compulsory
education system in Montana, which requires attendance through age
sixteen (16) under MCA 20-5-102, terminates structured
developmental support during eight (8) to nine (9) years of
critical neurological maturation;
(bb) Erik Erikson's model of psychosocial development (1959)
identifies eight stages of human development, each requiring the
resolution of a core developmental crisis. The stages from birth
through age twenty-five encompass Trust vs. Mistrust (ages 0-1),
Autonomy vs. Shame (ages 1-3), Initiative vs. Guilt (ages 3-6),
Industry vs. Inferiority (ages 6-12), Identity vs. Role Confusion
(ages 12-18), and Intimacy vs. Isolation (ages 18-25). Failure to
provide structured developmental support through these stages
results in incomplete psychosocial maturation;
(cc) Lev Vygotsky's Zone of Proximal Development (1934) establishes
that learning occurs in the gap between what an individual can
accomplish independently and what the individual can accomplish
with structured guidance. This theoretical framework requires
calibrated challenge — neither too easy nor too difficult — as the
mechanism of cognitive growth, and provides the scientific basis
for structured learning trials as an assessment methodology;
(dd) Robert Bjork's research on "desirable difficulties" (1994)
demonstrates that learning conditions that feel harder produce
superior retention and transfer of knowledge. Struggle is not a
side effect of learning but its mechanism, establishing the
scientific basis for structured challenge as a core pedagogical
method rather than passive attendance;
(ee) Suniya Luthar's research on the culture of affluence (2003,
National Institutes of Health PMC1950124) demonstrates that
affluent children exhibit elevated rates of substance abuse,
anxiety, and depression compared to inner-city peers. The
mechanism is achievement pressure without genuine challenge,
isolation from consequence, and absence of meaningful struggle.
Material abundance without developmental infrastructure produces
pathology. Education reform is therefore a prerequisite — not a
supplement — to the food and commodity assurance programs
established in this act;
(ff) The Legislature finds that material provision without social,
educational, and developmental infrastructure does not constitute
abundance for a social species. John B. Calhoun's "behavioral
sink" experiments (1962-1973) are frequently misinterpreted as
evidence that material abundance causes social collapse. This
interpretation is incorrect. Calhoun placed mice in an enclosure
with unlimited food and water but no social infrastructure —
no education, no healthcare, no social roles, no conflict
resolution, no intergenerational knowledge transfer, no
governance. What collapsed was not abundance but inventory. The
mice never had abundance. They had food in a box.
Abundance for homo technologicus includes the full institutional
architecture that complex social species require: education,
healthcare, social roles, developmental structure, conflict
resolution mechanisms, and intergenerational knowledge transfer.
Humans have not been comparable to a simple organism in a box for
tens of thousands of years. A human infant with unlimited food
but no social contact does not thrive — it dies or develops
permanent cognitive damage, as documented in isolation studies,
cases of feral children, and extreme neglect cases.
Even a prehistoric human possessed fire, tools, clothing,
language, and tribal social structure. Humans co-evolved with
their technology. Strip it away and the organism is not "natural"
— it is broken. The question of how many engineers and how many
years would be required to build a single automobile from raw
materials with no prior automobiles existing illustrates how deep
the dependency runs. Human systems are not luxuries bolted onto
biology. They ARE the biology at this point.
The United States military commissary has operated for one hundred
fifty-seven years with no "behavioral sink" — because it exists
inside a system that provides all of the above: education
(military academies, training pipelines), healthcare (military
hospitals, TRICARE), social roles (rank, unit cohesion, chain of
command), conflict resolution (UCMJ, command authority),
intergenerational knowledge transfer (doctrine, mentorship), and
governance (the entire Department of Defense structure).
Calhoun himself identified in his later work that the collapse
was caused by the breakdown of social ROLES, not by material
provision. He called the phenomenon the "behavioral sink." The
social structure failed because it was never designed.
Luthar (2003, 2005) provides the human confirmation: children
given material wealth without developmental structure show HIGHER
rates of substance abuse, anxiety, and disconnection than children
of poverty. Division III of this act is the developmental
structure. Without it, material provision is inventory — and
inventory without architecture produces pathology;
(gg) Arnold van Gennep (1909) and Victor Turner (1969) documented
that virtually every human society creates structured ordeals for
adolescents — physical trials, endurance tests, isolation periods,
community service — as developmental infrastructure. Societies
that abandoned these structures did not produce freer human
beings; they produced developmentally incomplete ones;
(hh) Samuel Bowles and Herbert Gintis demonstrated in "Schooling in
Capitalist America" (1976) that the education system reproduces
class structure. However, the appropriate diagnostic framework,
described in the Historical Apoplexy literature as the "targeting
error" (Cooper, Paper V, 2025), recognizes that teachers are not
responsible for society-wide stratification. The ocean is
stratified; the cup is not. Education reform must address the
structural conditions of the system, not blame individual
educators;
(ii) Philip Jackson's "Life in Classrooms" (1968) identified the
"hidden curriculum" — crowds, evaluation, and power asymmetry —
as inherent features of institutional education at scale. E.D.
Hirsch's "Cultural Literacy" (1987) established that core
knowledge must reside in the individual's own mind, not merely
be accessible through external references, as the prerequisite
for democratic participation;
(jj) PIAAC 2023 (OECD, December 2024): 28% of US adults at
the lowest literacy level (up from 19% in 2017). 34% lowest
numeracy. 32% lowest problem-solving. Declining in 19 of 26
OECD countries. Compound-competency: ~1 in 6,700 American
adults meet a basic standard (2 sports, 2 languages, 12th-grade
subjects, 2 instruments) the German Gymnasium certifies as
ordinary;
ADAM SMITH AND WHOLE-HUMAN EDUCATION. Smith
wrote in Wealth of Nations Book V Ch I Pt III Art II:
"The man whose whole life is spent in performing a few
simple operations... generally becomes as stupid and
ignorant as it is possible for a human creature to
become."
His remedy: compulsory state-funded education. Smith was a
polymath (Theory of Moral Sentiments, 1759, seventeen years
before Wealth of Nations). To cite Smith for markets while
opposing what Smith demanded is to invoke an authority one
has not read;
(jj.5) Benjamin Bloom's Taxonomy of Educational Objectives (1956)
establishes a sequential hierarchy of cognitive skills —
Knowledge, Comprehension, Application, Analysis, Synthesis, and
Evaluation — that must be honored in sequence to produce genuine
intellectual development. The K-20 pipeline established in
Division III structures the curriculum so that each stage builds
upon the cognitive foundation of the prior stage, preventing the
pattern of Historical Apoplexy in which advanced credentialing
occurs without foundational mastery;
(kk) The Vitruvian Quotient framework (Cooper, 2025-2026) models
human intelligence as eight measurable domains mapped to
neurological substrates: Knowledge Quotient (KQ, temporal and
parietal cortices), Reasoning Quotient (RQ, prefrontal and
parietal cortices), Emotional Quotient (EQ, limbic system and
amygdala), Language Quotient (LQ, Broca's and Wernicke's areas),
Creative Quotient (CQ, default mode network), Social Quotient (SQ,
mirror neuron system and temporoparietal junction), Motor Quotient
(MQ, motor cortex and cerebellum), and Biological Quotient (BQ,
autonomic and hormonal regulation). VQ = KQ + RQ + EQ + LQ + CQ +
SQ + MQ + BQ. A twenty-five-year curriculum calibrated to develop
all eight quotients to full human maturity, scored without ceiling
via a compensatory framework where strength in one domain offsets
deficit in another, provides the scientific foundation for the
education modernization program established in this act;
(kk1) The Meyerhoff Scholars Program at UMBC, founded by Freeman
Hrabowski in 1988, has produced over 1,400 alumni with five times
the STEM PhD pursuit rate of matched comparisons. Montana's seven
tribal colleges already practice the cohort-based, community-
rooted developmental model Meyerhoff validated at scale. Division
III builds on both — the Meyerhoff mechanism and the tribal
college tradition — statewide;
FINDINGS RELATING TO MONTANA'S EDUCATIONAL INFRASTRUCTURE AND
TRIBAL PARTNERSHIP:
(ll) Montana's Indian Education for All Act (MCA 20-1-501),
rooted in Article X, Section 1(2) of the 1972 Montana
Constitution, mandates that all Montana schools teach about the
history, culture, and contemporary issues of Montana's American
Indian tribal nations. This is one of the most progressive
indigenous education mandates in the United States and represents
an existing commitment to the principle that education must
encompass the full cultural and developmental context of the
learner — precisely the principle that the Vitruvian Quotient
framework formalizes as the Cultural Quotient (CQ);
(mm) Montana has eight (8) federally recognized tribal nations
occupying seven (7) reservations: the Blackfeet Nation (Blackfeet
Reservation), the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes
(Flathead Reservation), the Crow Tribe (Crow Reservation), the
Fort Belknap Indian Community of the Assiniboine and Gros Ventre
Tribes (Fort Belknap Reservation), the Fort Peck Assiniboine and
Sioux Tribes (Fort Peck Reservation), the Northern Cheyenne Tribe
(Northern Cheyenne Reservation), the Chippewa Cree Tribe of the
Rocky Boy's Reservation, and the Little Shell Tribe of Chippewa
Indians (federally recognized 2019, headquartered in Great Falls);
(nn) Montana's seven tribal colleges — Blackfeet Community College,
Chief Dull Knife College, Fort Belknap College (Aaniiih Nakoda
College), Fort Peck Community College, Little Big Horn College,
Salish Kootenai College, and Stone Child College — are accredited
institutions that combine academic instruction with cultural
transmission, community development, language preservation, and
identity formation. They develop the full human within a cultural
context: Knowledge Quotient (KQ) through academics, Cultural
Quotient (CQ) through tribal history and language, Social
Quotient (SQ) through community engagement, Emotional Quotient
(EQ) through mentorship and cultural ceremonies. Montana's tribal
colleges are the closest existing model to what VQ-integrated
K-20 education looks like in practice. Division III does not
replace tribal colleges — it learns from them and extends their
principles to all Montanans;
(oo) Montana's higher education infrastructure includes the
Montana University System governed by the Board of Regents: the
University of Montana (Missoula), Montana State University
(Bozeman), and their affiliated campuses (UM Western, Montana
Tech, UM Helena College, MSU Billings, MSU Northern, Great Falls
College MSU), plus three community colleges (Flathead Valley
Community College, Dawson Community College, Miles Community
College). Montana State University's land-grant mission in
agriculture and engineering aligns directly with Division III's
practical development focus;
(pp) Montana's vast geography makes education delivery the hardest
logistics problem of any state in this series. Students one
hundred miles from the nearest campus require access. Montana has
been a leader in distance education out of necessity. Division III
must include robust distance and hybrid delivery provisions. This
makes Montana's implementation the model for all rural states. If
the K-20 pipeline works across 147,040 square miles with 1.14
million people and 7.4 people per square mile, the distribution
problem is solved for the hardest case;
(qq) Montana's total state budget for the 2025-2027 biennium is
approximately $16 billion, with general fund spending of
approximately $6.5 billion for the biennium ($3.5 billion FY2024,
$3.0 billion FY2025, Urban Institute State Fiscal Brief —
Montana). Montana currently spends approximately $169.4 million
annually on SNAP benefits distributed through commercial
retailers, where 75.7 cents of every food dollar pays for markup
rather than food production;
(rr) The Sassafras and Maple Research Foundation (SMRF), the first
non-partisan political trade school in the United States,
registered with the Colorado Department of Higher Education,
Division of Private Occupational Schools (DPOS), developed the
original version of this proposal for the State of Colorado in
2016. SMRF was founded by Imran Cooper with the express purpose
of training citizens in legislative drafting, policy analysis, and
democratic participation. The present legislation represents the
Montana adaptation, incorporating research from the Historical
Apoplexy series (Cooper, 2025-2026).
(2) The Legislature further finds that the programs established in
this act — food and commodity assurance, public health
intervention, and education modernization — are interdependent
components of a single policy framework. Material abundance
without developmental infrastructure produces the affluence
pathology documented by Luthar. Education without material
security cannot function because students cannot learn while
food-insecure. And neither program can achieve its purpose
without addressing the physiological damage that hierarchy and
poverty inflict on the human body. These three divisions must be
enacted together, and each is necessary for the others to succeed.
DIVISION I — MONTANA FOOD AND COMMODITY ASSURANCE ACT
SECTION 2. Title 80, chapter 1, Montana Code Annotated, is amended by adding a new part to read:
ARTICLE 1 Montana Food Assurance Program
80-1-201. Short title.
This part shall be known and may be cited as the "Montana Food
Assurance Act."
80-1-202. Definitions.
As used in this part, unless the context otherwise requires:
(1) "At-cost pricing" means the price of a food product calculated
as the sum of the direct production cost paid to the producer or
supplier plus a facility surcharge not to exceed five percent (5%)
of the production cost, with no additional profit margin, markup,
or marketing cost applied.
(2) "Department" means the Montana Department of Agriculture.
(3) "Food assurance center" means a state-operated facility
established under this part for the purpose of distributing
food products to Montana residents at at-cost pricing.
(4) "Facility surcharge" means a charge not to exceed five percent
(5%) of the production cost of a food product, applied to cover
the operational costs of a food assurance center, including but
not limited to facility maintenance, labor, utilities, and
transportation.
(5) "Production cost" means the cost of producing a food product
as determined by the department based on wholesale acquisition
price from producers, cooperatives, or the most proximate point
in the supply chain to the point of original production.
(6) "Resource library" means the distribution system established
under Division IV of this act in which goods are distributed
according to need and tiered by permanence.
(7) "Tribal food sovereignty program" means a food production,
processing, or distribution program operated by or in partnership
with one of Montana's federally recognized tribal nations,
including but not limited to buffalo restoration programs,
traditional food systems, community gardens, and tribally
operated food distribution centers.
80-1-203. Montana food assurance program — creation — purpose.
(1) There is hereby created in the Department of Agriculture the
Montana food assurance program.
(2) The purpose of the program is to establish state-operated food
distribution centers where all Montana residents may purchase the
full range of grocery products at at-cost pricing, modeled on the
United States military commissary system as authorized by 10
U.S.C. Section 2484 and as operated by the Defense Commissary
Agency (DeCA) continuously since 1867.
(3) The program shall:
(a) Establish and operate food assurance centers throughout
the state of Montana;
(b) Purchase food products directly from Montana producers,
cooperatives, and wholesale suppliers at or near production
cost;
(c) Sell food products to Montana residents at at-cost
pricing as defined in section 80-1-202;
(d) Prioritize procurement from Montana farms, ranches, and
tribal food sovereignty programs to the maximum extent
practicable, with a target of sixty percent (60%)
Montana-sourced products within three years and seventy-five
percent (75%) within five years;
(e) Accept all forms of payment including but not limited to
cash, electronic benefit transfer (EBT), Supplemental
Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits, and Women,
Infants, and Children (WIC) vouchers;
(f) Operate without profit motive, with all revenue above
operational costs reinvested in program expansion;
(g) Establish partnerships with Montana's tribal nations for
food sovereignty programs, including but not limited to
buffalo restoration, traditional food systems, indigenous
seed banks, and tribally operated distribution points on
or near reservations.
80-1-204. Pilot food assurance centers — locations — timeline.
(1) Within two (2) years of the effective date of this part, the
department shall establish not fewer than five (5) pilot food
assurance centers in the following regions:
(a) One (1) center in the Billings metropolitan area;
(b) One (1) center in the Missoula metropolitan area;
(c) One (1) center in the Great Falls metropolitan area,
with particular consideration for proximity to the Little
Shell Tribe community and Malmstrom Air Force Base;
(d) One (1) center serving the Blackfeet Reservation and
surrounding communities, located in consultation with the
Blackfeet Nation;
(e) One (1) center serving the Crow or Northern Cheyenne
Reservation and surrounding communities, located in
consultation with the respective tribal governments.
(2) Within five (5) years of the effective date of this part,
the department shall expand the program to not fewer than twelve
(12) food assurance centers statewide, including:
(a) At least one center per congressional district;
(b) At least one center within or adjacent to each of
Montana's seven reservations, developed in partnership with
the relevant tribal government;
(c) At least two (2) centers serving rural communities as
defined by the department, with priority given to communities
more than fifty (50) miles from the nearest full-service
grocery store.
(3) The department shall prioritize locations with the highest
rates of food insecurity, the greatest distances to existing
grocery retail, and the largest populations residing in food
deserts.
(4) Mobile food assurance units — refrigerated distribution
vehicles operating on regular routes — shall supplement fixed
centers in areas where population density does not support a
permanent facility, with not fewer than three (3) mobile units
operational within two years.
80-1-205. Montana food assurance fund — creation.
(1) There is hereby created in the state treasury the Montana
food assurance fund.
(2) The fund shall consist of:
(a) Appropriations made by the Legislature;
(b) Revenue generated by the facility surcharge;
(c) Federal grants and matching funds;
(d) Private donations and gifts;
(e) Any other money directed to the fund by law.
(3) Money in the fund is continuously appropriated to the
department for the purposes of this part.
80-1-206. Montana-first procurement.
(1) The department shall prioritize procurement from Montana-based
producers, ranches, farms, and tribal food sovereignty programs.
(2) Not less than sixty percent (60%) of all food products
distributed through food assurance centers shall be sourced from
Montana producers within three (3) years of the program's
effective date.
(3) Not less than seventy-five percent (75%) of all food products
distributed through food assurance centers shall be sourced from
Montana producers within five (5) years of the program's
effective date.
(4) The department shall establish contracts with Montana's tribal
nations for the procurement of buffalo meat, traditional foods,
and tribally produced agricultural products, with terms negotiated
directly with tribal governments.
80-1-207. Tribal food sovereignty partnership.
(1) The department shall establish a Tribal Food Sovereignty
Advisory Council consisting of one (1) representative designated
by each of Montana's eight federally recognized tribal nations and
one (1) representative of each of Montana's seven tribal colleges.
(2) The Advisory Council shall advise the department on:
(a) Location and design of food assurance centers on or
adjacent to reservations;
(b) Integration of traditional foods and culturally
appropriate products into food assurance center inventories;
(c) Buffalo restoration programs as food sovereignty
infrastructure;
(d) Indigenous seed preservation and traditional agricultural
practices;
(e) Tribally operated mobile distribution routes.
(3) No food assurance center shall be established on tribal land
without the express consent and partnership of the relevant
tribal government.
SECTION 3. Title 90, chapter 1, Montana Code Annotated, is amended by adding a new part to read:
ARTICLE 2 Montana Essential Goods Program
90-1-201. Montana essential goods program — creation.
(1) There is hereby created in the Department of Commerce the
Montana essential goods program.
(2) The program shall produce and distribute clothing, household
supplies, hygiene products, tools, educational materials, and
other essential goods at below-retail pricing through
manufacturing partnerships and direct procurement.
(3) The program shall prioritize partnerships with Montana-based
manufacturers and artisans, including tribal enterprises.
DIVISION II — MONTANA PUBLIC HEALTH AND WELFARE ACT
SECTION 4. Title 50, chapter 1, Montana Code Annotated, is amended by adding a new section to read:
50-1-131. Public health findings — hierarchy as medical condition.
(1) The Legislature finds and declares that food insecurity,
poverty, and social hierarchy are medical conditions with
documented physiological pathways, as established by:
(a) The Whitehall Studies (Marmot, 1967-present): 10,308
subjects demonstrating that the lowest employment grade
experienced three times the mortality of the highest grade,
independent of standard risk factors;
(b) Primate research (Sapolsky, 30 years): subordination
produces chronic elevated cortisol, atherosclerosis, and
immune suppression in wild baboon populations. When hierarchy
was disrupted, subordinates' cortisol normalized;
(c) Macaque research (Shively, 30 years): subordinate status
directly causes visceral fat accumulation, atherosclerosis,
and coronary artery disease through a cingulate cortex
serotonin pathway;
(d) Telomere research (Blackburn, 2009 Nobel Prize): chronic
psychological stress shortens telomeres, the protective caps
on chromosomal DNA, accelerating cellular aging.
(2) The food and commodity assurance programs established in
Division I of this act are hereby designated as public health
interventions.
(3) The Department of Public Health and Human Services shall:
(a) Conduct a baseline healthcare cost assessment within two
(2) years of the effective date of this section, establishing
the healthcare expenditures attributable to food insecurity,
poverty-related chronic stress, and hierarchy-related disease
in Montana;
(b) Submit annual reports to the Legislature documenting
healthcare cost reductions attributable to the programs
established in this act;
(c) Coordinate with Montana's tribal health agencies and
Indian Health Service facilities to measure reservation-
specific health outcomes, including diabetes rates, life
expectancy, cardiovascular disease, and suicide rates, with
reporting protocols developed in partnership with tribal
governments.
50-1-132. Reservation health equity.
(1) The Legislature finds that Montana's tribal reservations
experience some of the worst health outcomes in the United States,
with poverty rates ranging from twenty percent (20%) on the
Flathead Reservation to thirty-eight percent (38%) on the Northern
Cheyenne Reservation.
(2) The Department of Public Health and Human Services shall
establish reservation health equity benchmarks, developed in
partnership with tribal health agencies, and report annually on
progress toward closing the health disparity gap between
reservation and non-reservation communities.
(3) Division II programs shall integrate with existing Indian
Health Service infrastructure and tribal health systems rather
than creating parallel structures.
50-1-133. Suicide prevention integration.
(1) The Legislature finds that Montana has had the highest or
among the five highest suicide rates in the nation for thirty
consecutive years, with a 2022 rate of 28.9 per 100,000
population.
(2) The programs established in Divisions I and III of this act
are recognized as structural suicide prevention interventions,
addressing the root causes — material insecurity, social
isolation, developmental abandonment, and lack of purpose — rather
than solely the proximate triggers.
DIVISION III — MONTANA EDUCATION MODERNIZATION ACT
This division is the largest division of this act and is non-negotiable. Without education reform, material abundance produces the affluence pathology documented by Luthar. Division I feeds the body. Division III develops the mind that directs it.
SECTION 5. MCA 20-5-102 is amended to read:
20-5-102. Compulsory enrollment and attendance.
(1) Every parent, guardian, or other person who is responsible for
the care of a child shall cause the child to attend school on a
regular basis as provided in this section.
(2) A child shall attend a public or nonpublic school from the
age of seven (7) years until the child attains the age of
twenty-five (25) years, except as provided in subsection (3).
(3) A person who attains the age of eighteen (18) years may
satisfy the attendance requirement through enrollment in a
postsecondary education program that is part of the Montana K-20
education pipeline established in [this act], or through an
alternative educational pathway approved by the Board of Regents.
(4) The K-20 education pipeline established in this act provides
a seamless educational pathway from kindergarten through
approximately age twenty-five, encompassing approximately twenty
(20) grade levels, integrating the K-12 system and all public
postsecondary institutions in Montana into a single developmental
framework.
SECTION 6. Title 20, Montana Code Annotated, is amended by adding a new chapter to read:
CHAPTER 26 Montana K-20 Education Pipeline
20-26-101. Short title.
This chapter shall be known and may be cited as the "Montana
Education Modernization Act."
20-26-102. Montana K-20 education pipeline — creation — purpose.
(1) There is hereby created the Montana K-20 education pipeline,
a continuous educational pathway from kindergarten through
approximately age twenty-five, integrating:
(a) The Montana K-12 public school system;
(b) The Montana University System, including the University
of Montana, Montana State University, and all affiliated
campuses;
(c) Montana's three community colleges: Flathead Valley
Community College, Dawson Community College, and Miles
Community College;
(d) Montana's seven tribal colleges, as full partners in the
pipeline with their existing accreditation, governance, and
cultural mission preserved and protected.
(2) The purpose of the K-20 pipeline is to provide structured
developmental support through the full maturation of the human
prefrontal cortex (approximately age 25), integrating academic
instruction with the eight developmental domains of the Vitruvian
Quotient framework.
20-26-103. Automatic postsecondary admission.
(1) Upon completing secondary education, every Montana resident
is entitled to continue in the K-20 pipeline at a public
institution of higher education through a placement process
administered by the Board of Regents, replacing the competitive
application model for K-20 pipeline enrollment.
(2) Placement shall consider student aptitude, geographic
proximity, institutional capacity, and alignment with the
student's developmental profile across all eight VQ domains.
(3) Students shall have the right to request placement at
tribal colleges where culturally appropriate, regardless of
tribal enrollment status, subject to institutional capacity
and the tribal college's admission policies.
20-26-104. Fully funded in-state tuition.
(1) In-state tuition and mandatory fees at all public
postsecondary institutions in the Montana University System are
fully funded for Montana residents enrolled in the K-20 pipeline.
(2) Tribal colleges participating in the K-20 pipeline shall
receive equivalent per-student funding to ensure tribal college
students receive the same financial support as students at
Montana University System institutions.
(3) A needs-based living stipend is established for students
below two hundred percent (200%) of the federal poverty level,
in an amount sufficient to cover housing, food, transportation,
and educational materials.
(4) Montana's distance and hybrid learning infrastructure shall
be expanded to serve students in remote communities, including
reservation communities, who cannot relocate to a campus.
20-26-105. VQ-aligned curriculum.
(1) The Board of Regents, in consultation with the Superintendent
of Public Instruction and Montana's tribal education departments,
shall develop a VQ-aligned curriculum mapping the eight quotients
of the Vitruvian Quotient framework to Erikson's psychosocial
stages across five developmental stages:
STAGE ONE: FOUNDATION (Ages 0-6) — Trust, Autonomy, Initiative.
Focus on Biological Quotient (BQ), Emotional Quotient (EQ),
Motor Quotient (MQ), and Language Quotient (LQ). Sensorimotor
development, attachment, early language acquisition, and physical
coordination.
STAGE TWO: KNOWLEDGE ACQUISITION (Ages 6-12) — Industry vs.
Inferiority. Focus on Knowledge Quotient (KQ), Reasoning Quotient
(RQ), and Social Quotient (SQ). Core academic foundations, logical
reasoning, cooperative learning, and introduction to cultural
literacy (Hirsch) including Indian Education for All content.
STAGE THREE: IDENTITY FORMATION (Ages 12-18) — Identity vs. Role
Confusion. Focus on Creative Quotient (CQ), Cultural Quotient
(as subset of SQ), and integration of all eight domains. Advanced
academic specialization, artistic expression, vocational
exploration (Holland RIASEC model), community engagement, and
structured learning trials replacing passive attendance.
STAGE FOUR: INTEGRATION AND MASTERY (Ages 18-24) — Intimacy vs.
Isolation. Full integration of all eight VQ domains through
postsecondary education. Structured challenge increases through
Bjork's desirable difficulties. Intellectual lineage requirements:
students must trace the chain of discovery in their field,
preventing Historical Apoplexy (Cooper, 2025). Compensatory
scoring: strength in one quotient offsets deficit in another.
Van Gennep/Turner structured ordeals as developmental milestones.
STAGE FIVE: LEADERSHIP AND TRANSITION (Age 25) — Citizen
readiness. Final assessment of developmental maturity across all
eight VQ domains. Transition to post-pipeline public service.
Preparation for full participation as a citizen of the Republic.
(2) The VQ-aligned curriculum shall build upon and extend the
Indian Education for All mandate (MCA 20-1-501) by integrating
tribal knowledge systems, indigenous science, and cultural
practices as core content throughout all five stages, not as
supplementary or elective material.
(3) Structured learning trials shall replace passive attendance
as the primary measure of educational progress, based on
Vygotsky's Zone of Proximal Development and Bjork's desirable
difficulties.
(4) The targeting error protection shall apply: Teachers shall
not be held individually accountable for student outcomes
attributable to structural conditions outside the educator's
control (poverty, food insecurity, housing instability), based
on Bowles and Gintis (1976) corrected by Cooper (2025). The
stratification is society-wide; education reflects it but did
not create it.
20-26-106. Tribal college partnership.
(1) Montana's tribal colleges are recognized as full and equal
partners in the K-20 pipeline, not subordinate institutions to
be integrated into the Montana University System hierarchy.
(2) Tribal colleges participating in the K-20 pipeline shall
retain:
(a) Complete autonomy over curriculum content related to
tribal culture, language, and knowledge systems;
(b) Self-governance and existing accreditation;
(c) The right to develop culturally integrated VQ assessment
methods that honor tribal values and epistemologies;
(d) Priority in designing Division III implementation for
reservation communities.
(3) The Board of Regents shall establish transfer agreements
with all seven tribal colleges ensuring that credits transfer
seamlessly between tribal colleges and Montana University System
institutions.
(4) Montana's tribal colleges represent the closest existing
model to VQ-integrated K-20 education. The Montana University
System shall study and learn from tribal college methods of
whole-human development, not impose external frameworks upon them.
20-26-107. Distance and hybrid education delivery.
(1) The Board of Regents shall establish a Montana Distance
Learning Network connecting all K-20 pipeline institutions —
including tribal colleges — with high-bandwidth interactive
instruction capability.
(2) Every Montana community with a population of five hundred
(500) or more shall have access to a K-20 pipeline learning
center, either as a physical location or through distance
learning technology deployed at existing community facilities
(libraries, schools, tribal community centers).
(3) Montana's implementation of the K-20 pipeline through distance
and hybrid delivery across 147,040 square miles serves as the
national model for rural education infrastructure. If the pipeline
works in Montana, it works in every rural state.
20-26-108. Intellectual lineage and cultural literacy.
(1) Every graduating student must trace the chain of discovery in
their field, engage with primary sources, and demonstrate the
shared knowledge base necessary for democratic participation
(Hirsch, 1987). This prevents Historical Apoplexy — the loss of
civilizational memory (Cooper, 2025).
(2) The Analogue Knowledge Base requirement ensures that students
carry the knowledge internally, not merely know how to access it
through external references. Benjamin Bloom's Taxonomy of
Educational Objectives (1956) — Knowledge, Comprehension,
Application, Analysis, Synthesis, and Evaluation — shall be
honored in sequence throughout the K-20 pipeline.
(3) Montana's Indian Education for All content shall be integrated
throughout the intellectual lineage curriculum, ensuring that the
chain of discovery includes indigenous knowledge, indigenous
science, and indigenous governance alongside Western academic
traditions.
20-26-109. The Butte lesson — anti-extraction education principle.
(1) The Legislature finds that Butte, Montana, produced the copper
that electrified America and received in return the Berkeley Pit —
a toxic Superfund site where 342 snow geese died in a single day.
The extraction economy removed human capital from Montana just as
it removed mineral wealth: young people educated in Montana left
for out-of-state employers, taking the state's developmental
investment with them.
(2) The K-20 pipeline shall be designed so that human development
stays in the community where it is produced. The post-pipeline
public service requirement established in Division IV is the
anti-extraction mechanism: Montanans developed through the K-20
pipeline serve Montana first. This does not prohibit out-of-state
employment after public service completion; it ensures that the
state's investment in each citizen is returned to the state
before market forces distribute the talent.
(3) Montana State University's land-grant mission — agriculture,
engineering, applied science — aligns directly with this
anti-extraction principle. The K-20 pipeline channels Montana's
educational output toward Montana's productive capacity: feeding
Montanans, building Montana's infrastructure, and serving
Montana's communities.
20-26-110. Small-state scalability advantage.
(1) Montana is the smallest-population state in this legislative
series with a citizen initiative process. With 1.14 million people
across 147,040 square miles — the fourth-largest state by area,
forty-fourth by population, with a density of 7.4 persons per
square mile — Montana is the scalability test at the sparse
extreme.
(2) If the K-20 pipeline achieves full coverage across Montana's
geography — serving students in Billings and on the Northern
Cheyenne Reservation, in Missoula and in the Bull Mountains, in
Great Falls and in communities one hundred miles from the nearest
campus — then the distribution problem is solved for the hardest
case in the nation.
(3) Montana and California together prove the model at both
extremes: Montana proves rural, sparse, geographically vast;
California proves urban, dense, demographically complex. If the
K-20 pipeline works in both, it works everywhere.
(4) Montana's strong community identity, its everyone-knows-
everyone culture in rural communities, and its tradition of
neighbor-helping-neighbor are assets that larger states cannot
replicate. The K-20 pipeline leverages these social bonds as
developmental infrastructure — precisely the social architecture
that Calhoun's mice lacked and that Luthar's affluent children
were denied.
20-26-111. Structured assessment and developmental milestones.
(1) The K-20 pipeline shall replace the passive attendance model
with structured assessment at developmental milestones aligned
to Erikson's psychosocial stages and Bloom's cognitive taxonomy:
(a) Foundation Assessment (Age 6-7): Readiness for formal
instruction. BQ, EQ, MQ, and LQ baseline. Trust and autonomy
development confirmed.
(b) Knowledge Assessment (Age 12): Core academic foundations
in literacy, numeracy, scientific reasoning, and cultural
literacy (Hirsch). Industry vs. Inferiority resolution.
Indian Education for All competency assessment.
(c) Identity Assessment (Age 18): Secondary completion.
All eight VQ domains assessed. Identity vs. Role Confusion
resolution. Vocational exploration profile (Holland RIASEC).
Structured learning trials demonstrating mastery beyond
attendance.
(d) Integration Assessment (Age 24): Postsecondary mastery.
Intellectual lineage demonstration. Compensatory VQ scoring
applied. Desirable difficulties (Bjork) documentation.
Van Gennep/Turner structured ordeal completion.
(e) Citizen Readiness Assessment (Age 25): Final
developmental maturity across all eight VQ domains. Transition
to post-pipeline public service. Preparation for full
participation as a citizen of the Republic.
(2) No student shall be denied progression for failure at a
single milestone. The compensatory framework ensures that
strength in one VQ domain offsets deficit in another. Assessment
identifies where additional scaffolding is needed (Vygotsky ZPD),
not where students are excluded.
(3) High performers may accelerate; students requiring additional
developmental time may extend beyond age 25 without penalty.
The pipeline is calibrated to human development, not arbitrary
timelines.
20-26-112. The 1972 Constitution and education.
(1) Article X, Section 1 of the Montana Constitution commits the
state to developing "the full educational potential of each
person" and to recognizing "the distinct and unique cultural
heritage" of Montana's American Indian people. Division III
operationalizes both mandates simultaneously: the K-20 pipeline
develops full educational potential through age 25, and the
integration of Indian Education for All throughout all five
developmental stages honors the cultural heritage mandate.
(2) The 1972 Constitutional Convention delegates, who wrote the
most progressive state constitution of the twentieth century in
explicit opposition to the Anaconda Company's control of Montana,
envisioned an education system that served the people rather than
extractive interests. Division III fulfills that vision: education
calibrated to human development, not to labor market extraction;
citizens developed for Montana, not as products for export.
DIVISION IV — MONTANA PUBLIC SERVICE AND RESOURCE LIBRARY
SECTION 7. Title 2, chapter 15, Montana Code Annotated, is amended by adding a new part to read:
PART 40 Montana Public Service and Resource Library
2-15-4001. Public service requirement — creation.
(1) There is hereby established a post-K-20-pipeline public
service requirement of two (2) to four (4) years of approved
public service, typically completed post-age-twenty-five adjunct
with Montana state university programs.
(2) Service categories include:
(a) State and local government service;
(b) Emergency and first responder services;
(c) Military service;
(d) Public education;
(e) Agricultural and manufacturing service;
(f) Tribal government or tribal enterprise service;
(g) Conservation and land management service;
(h) Healthcare and public health service;
(i) Community volunteer corps.
(3) Military service, Peace Corps, AmeriCorps, Tribal service
programs, and VISTA service shall be credited year-for-year.
(4) High and low performers may vary from the typical age-25
start point.
2-15-4002. Resource library — creation — tiers.
(1) There is hereby created the Montana resource library, a
distribution system for goods tiered by permanence, adapted from
the resource library model proposed by Jacque Fresco (2007):
(a) Constant-need goods (food, consumables): Available to all
Montana residents through at-cost food assurance centers;
(b) Semi-permanent goods (clothing, household supplies):
Available through essential goods program and resource
library;
(c) Permanent goods (appliances, one home, one vehicle):
Available to qualifying individuals, one-per-household for
housing;
(d) Currency tier (luxury, custom, specialty): Currency
survives for goods not covered by the resource library.
(2) THE UNLOCK MECHANISM: Full resource library access is granted
upon completion of BOTH the K-20 education pipeline (approximately
20 grades, through approximately age 25) AND the post-pipeline
public service requirement (2-4 years adjunct with state
university).
(3) The resource library does not eliminate the market economy;
it provides a floor of material security below which no qualifying
citizen falls.
DIVISION V — GENERAL PROVISIONS
SECTION 8. Appropriation.
The following amounts are appropriated from the general fund for
the biennium beginning July 1, 2027:
Department of Agriculture (food assurance): $20,000,000
Department of Commerce (essential goods): $8,000,000
Dept. of Public Health and Human Services: $3,000,000
Office of Public Instruction / Board of Regents: $50,000,000
Dept. of Administration (public service/
resource library): $6,000,000
Tribal partnership and food sovereignty grants: $8,000,000
TOTAL: $95,000,000
This total represents approximately 1.46% of Montana's
approximately $6.5 billion biennial general fund for the
2027-2029 biennium.
THE FEDERAL SNAP COST-SHIFT. Federal H.R. 1 (2025) increased
the state share of SNAP administrative costs from fifty percent
to seventy-five percent, effective October 1, 2026. This state
currently routes SNAP benefits through commercial retailers
where 75.7 cents of every food dollar pays for markup rather
than food. At at-cost routing through Division I, approximately
95 cents of every dollar reaches the recipient as food
(production cost plus five percent surcharge) — a 3.9-fold
increase in delivered food value per SNAP dollar that
independently offsets the federal cost-shift.
DIVISION I FOOD PROGRAM TARGET. The at-cost food assurance
program established in Division I, serving Montana's population
of approximately 1.08 million residents (MT.gov, Census 2025),
requires approximately $658 million per year at production cost
($609 per person per year for a full baseline of 37 staple food
items at 30 percent of cheapest retail price per USDA Food Dollar
Series methodology). Against Montana's annual budget of
approximately $8.2 billion ($16.46 billion biennial, NASBO HB 2
signed June 2025), this represents approximately 8 percent.
Montana's per-capita state spend of approximately $7,593 per
resident supports the full baseline. Verified April 18, 2026
via SearXNG.
THE FISCAL LOCK. The argument that Montana "cannot afford"
this Act is refuted by the state's existing expenditure on the
less efficient version of the same programs while absorbing a
federal SNAP cost-shift the state did not request. The fiscal
question is not whether to spend, but whether to continue
spending four times as much as required to accomplish the same
objective.
SECTION 9. Effective dates.
(1) Division I (Food Assurance): July 1, 2027 — pilot centers
operational within two years;
(2) Division II (Health): July 1, 2027 — baseline assessment
within two years;
(3) Division III (Education Modernization): The K-20 compulsory
education extension is phased in beginning with students entering
ninth grade in 2029-30, with the first full cohort completing the
pipeline in 2036-37. Full tuition funding phased in over three
fiscal years beginning FY 2028;
(4) Division IV (Public Service): July 1, 2030 — applies to the
first cohort completing the K-20 pipeline.
CONSTITUTIONAL EDUCATION OBLIGATION. Article X Section 1
of the Montana Constitution recognizes "the goal of
developing the full educational potential of each person"
and requires "equality of educational opportunity." Columbia
Falls Elementary School v. State (2005) held the Legislature
must fund education at a level that meets quality standards.
Division III completes this mandate.
SECTION 10. Severability.
If any provision of this act or its application to any person or
circumstance is held invalid, the remainder of the act and the
application of the provision to other persons or circumstances
is not affected.
SECTION 11. Tribal sovereignty.
(1) Nothing in this act shall be construed to diminish, modify,
or eliminate the sovereign authority of Montana's federally
recognized tribal nations.
(2) All programs established in this act that operate on tribal
land or serve tribal communities shall be developed and
administered in genuine partnership with the relevant tribal
government, pursuant to the government-to-government relationship
between Montana and its tribal nations.
(3) Tribal nations may elect to participate in, modify, or
decline any program established in this act as it applies to
their sovereign territory.
SECTION 12. Coordination with Montana Constitution.
(1) This act is enacted pursuant to and consistent with:
(a) Article II, Section 3 (right to a clean and healthful
environment);
(b) Article II, Section 10 (right to privacy);
(c) Article X, Section 1(2) (preservation of cultural
integrity of American Indian populations);
(d) Article III, Section 4 (initiative and referendum);
(e) Article XII, Section 1 (the Montana Constitution
controls when in conflict with statute).
(2) The Legislature declares that this act operationalizes the
constitutional framework envisioned by the delegates to the
1972 Montana Constitutional Convention.
SECTION 13. Safety clause.
This act is declared necessary for the immediate preservation
of the public peace, health, and safety.
LEGISLATIVE ROUTING NOTE
COMMITTEE ASSIGNMENT:
Senate Agriculture, Livestock, and Irrigation Committee
Senate Public Health, Welfare, and Safety Committee
Senate Education and Cultural Resources Committee
House Agriculture Committee
House Human Services Committee
House Education Committee
House Appropriations Committee
FLOOR VOTE:
Senate: Simple majority (26 of 50)
House: Simple majority (51 of 100)
Governor's signature or veto override (two-thirds)
REFERENCES
The research and citations supporting this act are drawn from:
FOOD AND COMMODITY ASSURANCE: - USDA Economic Research Service, Food Dollar Series (2023) - Military Commissary Act of 1867, 10 U.S.C. Section 2484 - Cooper, "The Mathematics of Abundance" (2025) — Paper III - FRAC, SNAP State Fact Sheet — Montana (February 2025) - USDA NASS, Montana Agricultural Statistics (2024) - Montana Free Press, "Montana still has more cows than people" (July 2025) - Fresco, "Designing the Future" (2007) — Resource library three-tier model - Galbraith, "The Affluent Society" (1958) - Veblen, "The Engineers and the Price System" (1921) - Cooper, "Stolen Futures" (2025) — Paper IV - Penck, Earth carrying capacity calculations (1925)
EXTRACTION HISTORY: - High Country News, Berkeley Pit snow geese (December 1995) - Audubon Society, Snow Geese Die in Poisonous Mine Waters (2016) - EPA, Butte Mine Flooding Operable Unit Fact Sheet (2019) - Malmstrom Air Force Base, 341st Missile Wing Fact Sheet
PUBLIC HEALTH AND HIERARCHY: - Marmot, The Whitehall Studies (1967-present) - Marmot, "The Status Syndrome" (2004) - Sapolsky, "Why Zebras Don't Get Ulcers" (1994); "Behave" (2017) - Shively, Social Stress and Coronary Artery Atherosclerosis (2009) - Blackburn & Epel, "The Telomere Effect" (2017) - Montana DPHHS, Suicide in Montana Report (September 2023) - Montana Department of Labor and Industry, Reservation Economies (2024)
EDUCATION AND HUMAN DEVELOPMENT: - Erikson, Childhood and Society (1959) - Vygotsky, Mind in Society (1934/1978) - Bjork, "Desirable Difficulties" (1994) - Luthar, "The Culture of Affluence" (2003) - Calhoun, "Death Squared" (1973) / Universe 25 experiments (1962-1973) - van Gennep, "The Rites of Passage" (1909) - Turner, "The Ritual Process" (1969) - Bowles & Gintis, "Schooling in Capitalist America" (1976) - Cooper, "The Targeting Error" (2025) — Paper V - Jackson, "Life in Classrooms" (1968) - Hirsch, "Cultural Literacy" (1987) - Bloom, "Taxonomy of Educational Objectives" (1956) - Gardner, "Frames of Mind" (1983) - Goleman, "Emotional Intelligence" (1995) - Bar-On, "The Emotional Quotient Inventory" (1997) - Holland, "Making Vocational Choices" (1959/1997) - Smith, "The Wealth of Nations" (1776) - Cooper, "Historical Apoplexy" (2025-2026) — Papers I through X - Cooper, "The Vitruvian Quotient" (2025-2026)
MONTANA-SPECIFIC: - Montana Constitution (1972) - Indian Education for All, MCA 20-1-501 - Montana tribalnations.mt.gov, Directory of Tribal Nations - Montana University System (mus.edu) - Montana Department of Labor and Industry, Reservation Economies - Urban Institute, State Fiscal Brief — Montana (2024) - Census Bureau, Montana QuickFacts (2025) - 1972 Montana Constitutional Convention (Wikipedia; U of Montana archives) - Ballotpedia, Signature requirements for ballot measures in Montana
END OF BILL
MONTANA FOOD, RESOURCE, AND COMMODITY ASSURANCE ACT Sixty-Ninth Legislature of the State of Montana 2025 Regular Session
Prepared by: The Amanuensis — theamanuensis.com Originally proposed: 2016 (Cooper, for Colorado) Montana adaptation: March 2026